Phones NOV 21, 2026 6 MIN READ

Microsoft Kin

My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.

Timeline of Microsoft Kin: 8 dated events from April 12, 2010 to December 2010, drawn from the entry's sources.Timeline of Microsoft Kin: 8 dated events from April 12, 2010 to December 2010, drawn from the entry's sources.
Every date is from the entry's sources below. An original diagram, free to reuse with a link to this page · Download the SVG
The timeline as text
  • April 12, 2010Microsoft announced Kin with Sharp, Verizon and Vodafone
  • May 2010Kin One and Kin Two went on sale at Verizon
  • June 2010Verizon cut the prices to $50 and $30
  • June 30, 2010Microsoft said it would focus exclusively on Windows Phone 7
  • July 2010Electronista reported Verizon was returning unsold Kins
  • July 30, 2010Microsoft's annual report noted charges for discontinuing Kin
  • November 2010Kin returned as a feature phone without its social features
  • December 2010Engadget reported Kin Studio would close on January 31, 2011
Company
Microsoft
Category
Phones
Launched
May 2010
Ended
June 2010
Stage reached
Introduction
AI product
No
Status
Microsoft dropped Kin on June 30, 2010; Kin Studio was due to close on January 31, 2011

Microsoft dropped its Kin phones 48 days after it began selling them, because of disappointing sales, The New York Times reported. Reporters blamed a smartphone data plan on phones with no app store, and Engadget also blamed a rebuild inside Microsoft that delayed Kin, which it said shipped unfinished.

What it was

Kin was a pair of social phones, the Kin One and the Kin Two, that Microsoft made with Sharp and sold only through Verizon in the US.

Microsoft announced Kin on April 12, 2010, as a Windows Phone designed around people's social lives. Vodafone was to follow that autumn in Germany, Italy, Spain and the UK.

Both models had a touch screen and a slide-out keyboard. The home screen, called the Loop, pulled in feeds from Facebook, MySpace and Twitter. A feature called the Spot let you drag photos, links and people to one place to share them, and Kin Studio backed up texts, call history, photos, videos and contacts to the web.

Robbie Bach, president of Microsoft's Entertainment and Devices Division, described it in the announcement as "a phone that makes it easy to share your life moment to moment." He told CNET the target was men and women between 15 and 30.

Kin began as Project Pink under J Allard, a Microsoft executive, Engadget reported. In 2008 Microsoft bought Danger, the company behind the T-Mobile Sidekick. Roz Ho, the corporate vice president who led the Kin team, told ZDNet that Kin used none of Danger's Java-based code but drew on its approach to services.

What happened

Kin went on sale at Verizon in May 2010, and Microsoft dropped it at the end of June.

The Kin One cost $49.99 and the Kin Two $99.99 after a $100 mail-in rebate, Engadget's review said. Both needed Verizon's $29.99 monthly smartphone data plan on top of a voice plan. Computerworld put the minimum at $70 a month over a two-year contract.

In the last week of June, Verizon cut the prices to $50 for the Kin Two and $30 for the Kin One, TechFlash and The New York Times reported.

On June 30, 2010, Microsoft said it would "focus exclusively on Windows Phone 7," cancel Kin's European launch and move the Kin team into the Windows Phone 7 team, according to the statement Engadget published.

Neither company disclosed sales, the Times reported. Engadget's sources and a later Times article put the total at fewer than 10,000.

In mid-July, Electronista reported, citing two insiders, that Verizon was sending its unsold Kins back to Microsoft and had stopped selling them online.

Microsoft's annual report, filed on July 30, 2010, named "charges resulting from the discontinuation of the KIN phone" among the reasons its cost of revenue rose, with no separate figure for them.

Kin came back that November as a feature phone, with the Loop, the Spot, Kin Studio and the social networking removed, CNET reported. In December, Engadget reported that Kin Studio would close on January 31, 2011, and that Verizon would let Kin owners trade in for a free 3G phone through March 31.

Why it failed

Microsoft's statement gave no reason for dropping Kin beyond its shift to Windows Phone 7. Reporting blamed the data plan, the missing apps and a rebuild inside Microsoft that cost Kin time.

What Microsoft said

Microsoft's June 30 statement said it would fold "valuable ideas and technologies from KIN" into later Windows Phone releases and keep selling the current phones through Verizon. TechFlash's Todd Bishop wrote that Microsoft released it "without publicly acknowledging the reasons."

Microsoft had neither confirmed nor denied reports that only 500 Kins had sold, TechFlash reported.

In May, Microsoft and Verizon had defended the monthly fee, partly by pointing to Kin's automatic cloud backup, Computerworld reported. Greg Sullivan, a senior product manager at Microsoft, called Kin "a new category that's not exactly a smartphone." He said that "over the longer term" Kin and Windows Phone 7 would merge and get downloadable apps.

What reporting showed

In Engadget's review, Joshua Topolsky wrote that offering "so much less than a smartphone with a smartphone data plan is insulting to consumers."

He also listed what Kin lacked: "No app store, no IM client, no games, no calendar." Instead, he pointed readers to Verizon's Palm Pre Plus at $29 with a smartphone and voice plan, "an immeasurably better phone."

Gizmodo's Matt Buchanan wrote on the day Kin died that "Verizon priced Kin's monthly service like a smartphone, even though it wasn't one." In November, CNET's Josh Lowensohn called its steep data pricing "arguably one of the Kin's weakest points."

One source told Engadget that Andy Lees, the senior vice president who ran Microsoft's mobile division, had ordered the team to rebuild Kin on Windows CE instead of Danger's Sidekick software, a move that "allegedly set the release of the devices back 18 months." By launch, the source said, Verizon no longer planned to offer the cheap pricing deals it had first proposed.

Two days later, Engadget's inside story said Lees had taken the project from Allard and saw it as "little more than a contractual obligation to Verizon." Engadget said it had confirmed that, before launch, the planned data pricing "had changed and become much more expensive." Its sources said the team's calls for "huge, critical missing features like an app store fell on deaf ears." In Engadget's words, the team was "forced to release a phone that was practically raw in the middle."

A Microsoft executive close to the project told The New York Times that Microsoft staff who visited Verizon stores anonymously found the carrier's employees "reluctant to sell the Kin." Verizon tended to promote Android phones, the Times wrote.

Charles Golvin, a Forrester Research analyst, told the Times it was "an absolute failure" and said he was surprised Microsoft had killed it so quickly, given its history of sticking with new products.

What later analysis found

I found little later analysis of Kin. Writing in AllThingsD in 2013, Ina Fried said that "with no access to apps and competing against more capable phones, it was scrapped after little more than a month on the market."

The stage it reached

Kin died in the introduction stage, the launch period of the product life cycle, when awareness is low and sales are small.

Verizon cut both prices within weeks of launch, a mark of the stage.

Fewer than 10,000 sold, by the reported counts, so I don't think Kin found a market to lose. I count it as a failure, not a decline.

The lesson

I think Kin's lesson is that the monthly bill is part of the product, even when a partner sends it.

Microsoft built a phone for people between 15 and 30 and left that bill to Verizon. By Engadget's account, the cheaper data plan Kin was meant to sell on was gone before launch, and Kin shipped anyway, without the app store its own team had asked for.

If your product depends on a partner's pricing, I'd agree the full monthly cost before you build, and decide in advance what you'll do if the partner changes it.

Causes at a glance

  • Reporting at the timePricing

    Verizon required a $29.99 smartphone data plan on phones that weren't smartphones

    Sources4,7,15

  • Reporting at the timeMissing apps, content or partners

    No app store, no games and no instant messaging at launch

    Sources2,4,11,17

  • Reporting at the timeRushed launch

    By Engadget's account, a rebuild on Windows CE delayed it and it shipped unfinished

    Sources10,11

  • Reporting at the timeWeak demand

    Fewer than 10,000 sold in total, Engadget's sources and the Times reported

    Sources9,11,12

  • Company statementChange of company strategy

    Microsoft said it would focus exclusively on Windows Phone 7

    Sources6,8

Sources

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
    CNET, Microsoft's Kin: What it is-and isn't

    April 2010 · Reporting at the time

  3. 3.
    ZDNet, Microsoft's Ho: The Kin is not a 'Microsoft phone'

    April 2010 · Reporting at the time

  4. 4.
    Engadget, Microsoft Kin One and Two review

    May 2010 · Reporting at the time

  5. 5.
    Computerworld, Microsoft, Verizon defend Kin's monthly pricing, noting cloud backup

    May 2010 · Reporting at the time

  6. 6.
    Engadget, Microsoft Kin is dead

    June 2010 · Reporting at the time

  7. 7.
    Gizmodo, Microsoft Kills Kin

    June 2010 · Reporting at the time

  8. 8.
    TechFlash, Confirmed: Microsoft Kin is dead

    June 2010 · Reporting at the time

  9. 9.
    The New York Times, Microsoft Kin Discontinued After 48 Days

    June 2010 · Reporting at the time

  10. 10.
    Engadget, What killed the Kin?

    June 2010 · Reporting at the time

  11. 11.
    Engadget, Life and death of Microsoft Kin: the inside story

    July 2010 · Reporting at the time

  12. 12.
    The New York Times, Microsoft Calling. Anyone There?

    July 2010 · Reporting at the time

  13. 13.
    Electronista, Verizon returns unsold Kin phones, pulls online sales

    July 2010 · Reporting at the time

  14. 14.
    Microsoft (SEC filing), Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2010

    July 2010 · Company statement

  15. 15.
    CNET, Kin's quiet return a rarity among failed gadgets

    November 2010 · Reporting at the time

  16. 16.
  17. 17.

Share this entry