Apps and online services AI NOV 16, 2026 6 MIN READ

Forward CarePod

My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.

Timeline of Forward CarePod: 7 dated events from 2016 to December 13, 2024, drawn from the entry's sources.Timeline of Forward CarePod: 7 dated events from 2016 to December 13, 2024, drawn from the entry's sources.
Every date is from the entry's sources below. An original diagram, free to reuse with a link to this page · Download the SVG
The timeline as text
  • 2016Adrian Aoun and three co-founders started Forward
  • 2017Began opening its tech-first primary care clinics
  • November 15, 2023Announced the CarePod with $100 million in new funding
  • November 15, 2023Planned 25 CarePods at first and 3,200 within a year
  • March 2024Laid off a significant portion of staff, ex-employees said
  • November 12, 2024Closed its locations and app, effective immediately
  • December 13, 2024Last day of email support from its medical team
Company
Forward
Category
Apps and online services
Launched
November 2023
Ended
November 2024
Stage reached
Introduction
AI product
Yes
Status
Forward closed all its locations and its app, effective immediately, on November 12, 2024

Forward failed because its CarePods, self-serve AI doctor's offices, drew fewer patients than it hoped and often failed at basics like drawing blood, former employees told Business Insider. It planned 3,200 pods in a year, said a year later it had launched five, and shut down in November 2024 without giving a reason.

What it was

The Forward CarePod was a booth in a mall or office where members gave themselves a check-up, with software guiding them and Forward's doctors reviewing the results remotely.

Forward called it "The World's First AI Doctor's Office" in its launch announcement. Fortune described "a shiny eight-foot-by-eight-foot cube".

You opened the door with your phone and stepped in alone, TechCrunch reported, to find a chair, a large touchscreen and a hidden drawer that handed you tests. The pod could take your blood pressure, swab your throat and draw blood with a needleless device.

"Custom AI powers the diagnosis," according to TechCrunch, and doctors wrote any prescription behind the scenes. An attendant serviced each pod between uses but didn't go in with patients. Forward's announcement said its clinicians "make all care decisions".

Memberships started at $99 per month, the announcement said in November 2023. Forward didn't take insurance.

TechCrunch reported that Adrian Aoun, who had run special projects at Google, founded Forward in 2016 with three others, and that it started opening tech-first primary care clinics in 2017. At the CarePod launch, Forward said it had 19 locations and more than 100 primary care clinicians.

What happened

Forward announced the CarePod on November 15, 2023, with $100 million in new funding.

It planned to launch 25 CarePods in its first release and 3,200 within a year, TechCrunch reported, starting in the San Francisco Bay Area, New York, Chicago and Philadelphia. One was going into Chicago's Willis Tower.

TechCrunch put Forward's total funding at $657.5 million. Forbes estimated about $450 million, and Aoun wouldn't give a figure.

Aoun told Fierce Healthcare that Forward would put its money into CarePods rather than new clinics. "We're going to scale the pods far more," he told Forbes, "but we're keeping the clinics."

Four former employees later told Business Insider that Forward closed at least two clinics after the launch, in Dallas and in Bellevue, Washington. Leadership told staff the closures were partly so Forward could focus on the CarePod, they said.

In March 2024, Forward laid off a significant portion of its staff, seven former employees said. Two said it was then set to run out of money in less than a year.

Late on November 12, 2024, Forward emailed patients that it was closing all its locations, canceling scheduled visits and cutting off its app immediately, Business Insider reported. That morning it had still been emailing prospective customers discount offers.

A notice on its website said its medical team would support members by email until December 13, 2024. The Information reported that all of Forward's nearly 200 employees would lose their jobs, according to Fierce Healthcare.

Twelve months after the plan for 3,200 pods, Forward said it had launched five, Business Insider reported. Just before the closure, its website listed two CarePod locations.

Why it failed

Forward gave no reason when it shut down. Former employees who spoke to Business Insider described pods that drew fewer patients than Forward had hoped and often didn't work.

What Forward said

The closure notice didn't say why. It said Forward was shutting down effective immediately, and that it had been "a privilege to provide the world's best preventive care" for eight years. Forward didn't answer requests for comment from Business Insider or Fierce Healthcare.

"Basically, what I'm doing is slowly migrating every single thing from a doctor and nurse to hardware and software," Aoun told TechCrunch at launch, explaining the pods. "We don't even believe a doctor's office should exist."

He told Forbes the limiting factor of a doctor's office was "the doctors, they're super expensive and there's not many of them." Forward wasn't profitable, he confirmed to the magazine.

What reporting showed

The most detailed account I found came from eleven former employees who spoke to Business Insider before the closure, on condition of anonymity.

Six said fewer patients than Forward had hoped tried the pods. Three, two of them former sales staff, said the CarePod teams struggled to draw new customers once the early fascination wore off, and rarely hit sales targets.

Technical problems mounted too, by these accounts. Three former employees said patients frequently got stuck inside, especially in 2023 and early 2024.

The same three said the self-service blood draws routinely failed to collect enough blood through the first half of 2024. One estimated they failed "well over half the time."

Six said each pod was extremely expensive to manufacture, and four said the first two cost more than $1 million each.

Landlords were a hard sell too, Business Insider reported. The pods still had to meet building codes but couldn't show they were worth the floor space. Two former employees blamed logistical problems with the building for the Willis Tower pod, which never opened.

Forward was also burning cash in a hard fundraising market, the outlet added.

At the closure, Fierce Healthcare reported that some industry observers thought Forward "focused too much on tech rather than clinical care."

On launch day, Arthur Caplan, a bioethics professor at New York University, told Forbes that "the solution then isn't to go to jukebox medicine." He argued that it takes a doctor's "sophisticated interview" to draw out what patients don't want to say.

The stage it reached

The CarePod died in the introduction stage, where sales are small and costs run well ahead of revenue.

I found no membership numbers from Forward, and Aoun declined to share them at launch, Forbes reported. So I'm judging by the pod counts.

It never reached growth, which the product life cycle defines as adoption accelerating and unit costs falling as volume builds. I found no report of either. Decline doesn't fit, because the pods never found a market to lose.

The lesson

I think Forward's mistake was promising a rollout before its hardest step worked without a professional in the room.

That step was the blood draw. Clinicians are trained to draw the right amount, Business Insider noted, and a member alone in a booth isn't. One former employee said patients often put the device where it couldn't draw enough.

Those failures showed up, by former staff's account, while Forward had launched five pods at most. The introduction stage post lists announcing dates you can't hit as a mistake, and Forward's 3,200 became the number Business Insider measured its five against.

Amazon Go, another physical service with AI at its core, also ended in the introduction stage. Both look to me like places designed outward from their technology instead of from the person walking in.

If your product hands a skilled person's task to the customer, count how often customers get it right on their own in a few locations. Announce the rollout number after that.

Causes at a glance

  • Reporting at the timeWeak demand

    Fewer patients than Forward hoped tried the pods, six former employees said

    Source7

  • Reporting at the timeQuality and reliability

    Former staff said blood draws routinely failed and patients got stuck inside

    Source7

  • Reporting at the timeBusiness model and costs

    The first two pods cost more than $1 million each to build, ex-staff said

    Source7

  • Reporting at the timeMissing apps, content or partners

    Landlords were a hard sell, and the promised Willis Tower pod never opened

    Sources2,7

  • Reporting at the timeUnclear value

    Critics said it put technology ahead of clinical care

    Sources3,8

Sources

  1. 1.
    Forward, Forward Raises $100M and Announces Forward CarePod

    November 2023 · Company statement

  2. 2.
  3. 3.
    Forbes, An AI Doctor In A Box Coming To A Mall Near You

    November 2023 · Reporting at the time

  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
    Forward, Closure notice to members on goforward.com

    November 2024 · Company statement

  7. 7.
    Business Insider, Inside Forward's failed attempt to revolutionize the doctor's office

    November 2024 · Reporting at the time

  8. 8.
    Fierce Healthcare, Primary care player Forward shutters after raising $400M, rolling out CarePods

    November 2024 · Reporting at the time

Share this entry