Consumer hardware NOV 21, 2026 7 MIN READ

Portal

My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.

Timeline of Portal: 8 dated events from October 8, 2018 to December 31, 2022, drawn from the entry's sources.Timeline of Portal: 8 dated events from October 8, 2018 to December 31, 2022, drawn from the entry's sources.
Every date is from the entry's sources below. An original diagram, free to reuse with a link to this page · Download the SVG
The timeline as text
  • October 8, 2018Facebook announced Portal and Portal+ at $199 and $349
  • October 16, 2018Facebook said Portal call data could be used to inform ads
  • November 8, 2018Portal and Portal+ began shipping
  • September 18, 2019Announced Portal Mini, a new Portal and Portal TV
  • September 21, 2021Announced Portal Go, a new Portal+ and Portal for Business
  • June 2022Reports said Meta would stop making consumer Portals
  • November 11, 2022Executives told staff Meta was exiting the Portal business
  • December 31, 2022No longer on sale from this date, Meta's help page says
Company
Meta
Category
Consumer hardware
Launched
November 2018
Ended
December 2022
Stage reached
Introduction
AI product
No
Status
Not sold since December 31, 2022, Meta says; owners can still use them as apps are withdrawn

Facebook's Portal "never became a huge hit," The Verge wrote in 2022, noting that it did little besides video calls and that its tie to Facebook didn't offer much assurance about a camera in the home. Reviewers had made both complaints since launch, and Meta stopped selling Portal at the end of 2022.

What it was

Portal was a line of smart displays for video calls over Facebook Messenger, with a camera that panned and zoomed to keep everyone in frame.

Facebook (now Meta) announced the first two models on October 8, 2018: the 10-inch Portal at $199 and the 15-inch Portal+ at $349, both with Amazon's Alexa built in. The company said the camera's AI ran on the device, "not on Facebook servers," and it put a camera cover in the box.

Both came out of Building 8, Facebook's secretive hardware lab, TechCrunch reported. Recode noted that, Oculus's VR headsets aside, Portal was the company's first consumer hardware.

What happened

Portal shipped on November 8, 2018, The Verge reported, at a bad moment for Facebook.

The month before the announcement, Facebook had revealed a software flaw that let hackers into some 50 million accounts, Recode noted. Portal's release had reportedly been delayed for months after the Cambridge Analytica scandal, The Verge said.

Before Portal shipped, Facebook changed its account of the data. At the announcement, Portal's marketing lead, Dave Kaufman, told Recode that nothing collected through Portal would be used to target ads. On October 16, a spokesperson told Recode that Portal collected usage data such as "length of calls, frequency of calls," and that "We may use this information to inform the ads we show you across our platforms."

Facebook added three models on September 18, 2019: the 8-inch Portal Mini at $129, a new 10-inch Portal at $179 and Portal TV at $149, along with WhatsApp calls and six more countries. By October, Wired listed the Portal+ at $279.

During the pandemic, Facebook pitched Portal for work too, announcing Zoom, Webex, BlueJeans and GoToMeeting apps in August 2020. IDC estimated that Meta sold 600,000 Portals in 2020 and 800,000 in 2021, Engadget reported. The Verge, citing The Information, said IDC put Portal's 2021 share at less than 1 percent of the global smart speaker and display market.

On September 21, 2021, Facebook announced the battery-powered Portal Go at $199, a new 14-inch Portal+ at $349, and Portal for Business, then in closed beta. CNBC noted that Facebook hadn't revealed any Portal sales numbers.

In June 2022, The Information reported, and The Verge confirmed through a source, that Meta would stop making consumer Portals and aim the line at businesses.

Meta announced about 11,000 job cuts on November 9, 2022. On November 11, executives told staff at a town hall that Meta was exiting the Portal business, Reuters reported. The Verge added that Meta had dropped its plans to sell Portals to businesses too.

Meta's help page says Portal "hasn't been available for purchase since 31 December 2022." Owners can keep using their devices while apps are gradually withdrawn, it says, and there will be no next-generation Portal.

Why it failed

Reviewers and reporters put distrust of a Facebook camera in the home first among Portal's problems, and said that beyond calls it did less than Amazon's and Google's displays. Reporting tied its end in 2022 to Meta's cost cuts.

What Meta said

None of the Meta statements I found about Portal's end gives a reason. Asked about the consumer pivot in June 2022, Meta declined to comment, The Verge wrote. In April 2023, Meta added a line to an August 2022 newsroom post: "We are no longer selling Meta Portal and supported features may change over time."

Mark Zuckerberg's letter to staff on the day of the layoffs said Meta had to become "more capital efficient" and had moved resources to "a smaller number of high priority growth areas," the metaverse among them. It doesn't mention Portal.

Facebook named trust as the risk before launch. Andrew Bosworth, the executive responsible for the launch, told the BBC that "inviting a camera and microphone into your home is the kind of thing that will give a consumer pause." Rafa Camargo, Portal's vice president, told TechCrunch, "If no one wants it, ever, we will reassess."

What reporting showed

Trust came up on announcement day. Portal's success depended "not on functionality, but whether people are willing to put a Facebook camera and microphone in their home," TechCrunch's Josh Constine wrote.

The Verge titled its review "trust fail." Dan Seifert found Portal's calls better than on any other smart display he'd used, and still wrote that he was "deeply uncomfortable with the idea of a Facebook-connected camera in my home." He also pointed to Facebook's "mixed messaging" on ad data.

A year later, CNET's Megan Wollerton called Portal TV "a solidly performing, decently priced device" and still told readers "Don't buy it," citing privacy concerns about Facebook.

Reviewers also found little to do besides calls. "Outside of video calling, the Portal's functionality is rather limited," Seifert wrote, noting it had no Netflix and only a clumsy browser version of YouTube.

TechCrunch's Brian Heater called it "a bit of a one-hit wonder" next to the Echo Show and Google's Home Hub. A year on, a TechCrunch headline said Portal was "still searching for a reason to exist."

Amazon and Google already had smart displays on sale, The Verge noted at launch, and Google's Nest Hub Max had "adopted something similar" to Portal's tracking camera by 2019, Heater wrote. Portal "never quite sold as well" as Amazon's and Google's displays, Engadget reported in 2022.

When Meta dropped the consumer models in June 2022, The Verge recalled the displays' "limited functionality" and a tie to Facebook that "didn't offer a lot of assurance" about a camera at home, and wrote that Portal "never became a huge hit." It linked the decision to "investor concerns about the billions of dollars it's spending on projects that have yet to pay off financially." Reuters wrote in November that Meta "has aimed to shed costs as it refocuses on metaverse technologies."

The stage it reached

Portal never left the introduction stage, which the product life cycle guide describes as the launch period, when awareness is low and sales are small.

It showed the stage's signs. Facebook didn't disclose sales, it entered a category Amazon and Google already led, and about a year after launch the Portal+ cost $279, down from $349.

Sales rose during the pandemic, Engadget reported, but I don't count that as the growth stage, when sales rise fast on new customers. The 2021 estimate still left Portal under 1 percent of its market, and Meta decided the next year to stop making consumer models, The Verge reported.

The lesson

I think Portal is a clean case of a good product held back by its maker's reputation.

Facebook saw the problem coming and shipped a camera cover, a mute button and on-device AI. Then, eight days after the announcement, it took back what its marketing lead had told Recode about ads.

That reversal is the part I'd study. A product that asks for trust the company hasn't earned gets one chance to describe its data use, and a correction reads as proof of the fear.

Google Glass had to win over the people around the wearer. Portal sat in the buyer's own home and still had to win over the buyer.

If trust is your launch risk, settle every data question before announcement day, with the people who run the ads systems in the room.

Causes at a glance

  • Reporting at the timePrivacy and safety

    Reviewers balked at a Facebook camera and microphone at home after Cambridge Analytica

    Sources2,3,5,7,12,16

  • Reporting at the timeUnclear value

    Beyond video calls it did little; TechCrunch called it a one-hit wonder

    Sources7,8,10,16

  • Reporting at the timeCompetition

    Amazon and Google led smart displays; IDC put Portal under 1 percent in 2021

    Sources7,10,16,17

  • Reporting at the timeChange of company strategy

    Meta ended it amid cost cuts and a refocus on the metaverse, reporting said

    Sources16,19,20

Sources

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
    TechCrunch, Facebook launches Portal auto-zooming video chat screens for $199/$349

    October 2018 · Reporting at the time

  3. 3.
  4. 4.
    BBC News, Facebook Portal video chat screens raise privacy concerns

    October 2018 · Reporting at the time

  5. 5.
  6. 6.
    The Verge, Facebook's Portal video chat devices launch today

    November 2018 · Reporting at the time

  7. 7.
    The Verge, Facebook Portal review: trust fail

    November 2018 · Reporting at the time

  8. 8.
    TechCrunch, Facebook Portal+ review

    November 2018 · Reporting at the time

  9. 9.
  10. 10.
  11. 11.
    Wired, Facebook Portal (2019) Review: Mixed Feelings

    October 2019 · Reporting at the time

  12. 12.
    CNET, No one should buy the Facebook Portal TV

    November 2019 · Reporting at the time

  13. 13.
  14. 14.
    Facebook, Introducing Two New Portals, Including the First Portable Version

    September 2021 · Company statement

  15. 15.
  16. 16.
    The Verge, Meta will stop making Portal for consumers

    June 2022 · Reporting at the time

  17. 17.
    Engadget, Meta is reportedly discontinuing Portal devices for consumers

    June 2022 · Reporting at the time

  18. 18.
    Meta, Mark Zuckerberg's Message to Meta Employees

    November 2022 · Company statement

  19. 19.
    Reuters, Facebook parent Meta winding down some non-core hardware projects

    November 2022 · Reporting at the time

  20. 20.
    The Verge, Meta is killing Portal and both its unreleased smartwatches

    November 2022 · Reporting at the time

  21. 21.
  22. 22.
    Meta, Support for Meta Portal devices

    Company statement

Share this entry