Social networks NOV 19, 2026 7 MIN READ
Clubhouse
My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.
The timeline as text
- May 2020Andreessen Horowitz values the 1,500-user beta at about $100 million
- January 2021Andreessen Horowitz leads a round at a reported $1 billion value
- February 2021Downloads peak at 9.6 million in a month, Sensor Tower says
- April 2021Series C at a reported $4 billion as bigger rivals build copies
- May 2021Android app launches
- July 21, 2021Leaves beta and opens to everyone
- April 27, 2023Founders cut more than half the staff
- September 6, 2023Relaunches around Chats, asynchronous voice group chats
- January 2024Monthly users 93% below the June 2021 peak, Sensor Tower says
- Company
- Alpha Exploration Co.
- Category
- Social networks
- Launched
- March 2020
- Ended
- No end date
- Stage reached
- Decline
- AI product
- No
- Status
- Still running after 2023 layoffs and a relaunch; its Android app was updated on October 30, 2026
Clubhouse failed because its live rooms worked best when friends were on the app with time to talk, which got harder once lockdowns ended, its founders said, and because Twitter, Facebook and Spotify copied the rooms into platforms millions already used, reporters found. It was still running in November 2026, but Sensor Tower put its monthly users 93% below their 2021 peak by January 2024.
What it was
Clubhouse is a social audio app built around live rooms where some people talk and the rest listen.
"When you open the app you can see 'rooms' full of people talking," its founders, Paul Davison and Rohan Seth, wrote in July 2020. Listeners who want to talk raise a hand, and speakers can invite them up.
It began as an invite-only iPhone beta in the spring of 2020, made by Alpha Exploration Co. That May, Andreessen Horowitz valued it at about $100 million after a reported $12 million investment, when it had about 1,500 users, CNBC reported.
What happened
Clubhouse took off in early 2021. Davison said in January that it had 2 million weekly active users, and App Annie estimated its downloads rose from more than 3.5 million on February 1 to 8.1 million by February 16, after appearances by Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg, TechCrunch reported. Sensor Tower later told TechCrunch that February was its peak month, at 9.6 million downloads.
In January 2021, Andreessen Horowitz led a round at a reported $1 billion valuation. The Verge reported in April, citing Bloomberg, that Twitter had held talks to buy Clubhouse for around $4 billion and that the talks had stalled. Less than two weeks later, Clubhouse confirmed a Series C led by Andreessen Horowitz at a reported $4 billion, TechCrunch reported.
An Android app followed in May 2021. On July 21, Clubhouse left beta and opened to everyone, saying it would end its waitlist and invite system, TechCrunch reported.
Usage fell anyway. Sensor Tower said Clubhouse was downloaded 35 million times in 2021 and 3 million times in 2023, and that its monthly active users in January 2024 were 93% below their June 2021 peak, TechCrunch reported.
On April 27, 2023, Davison and Seth told staff that "we're scaling back our org by over 50%," in an email the company published. They had "years of runway remaining," they wrote.
That September, Clubhouse relaunched around Chats, voice-only group chats that take place asynchronously, "so you can drop by and chime in on your own time." Live rooms stayed, it said.
It was still available in November 2026. Its Android app was updated on October 30, 2026, and its Google Play listing still invited people to "jump into live audio rooms."
Why it failed
Clubhouse's founders blamed growing too fast and then the reopening after Covid, while reporting pointed to copies from bigger rivals, a shortage of relevant rooms and weak moderation.
What Clubhouse said
In April 2021, its blog said "our growth has outpaced the early discovery algorithms our small team originally built," TechCrunch reported. Davison told Bloomberg in late 2021 that it "grew way, way too fast," according to CNBC.
At TechCrunch Disrupt in October 2022, he said people who joined during the surge "had a really bad experience" because "everything was broken," and that for months afterwards newcomers "can't find good rooms," TechCrunch reported.
The 2023 layoff email blamed the reopening and the size of the team. Davison and Seth wrote that "as the world has opened up post-Covid, it's become harder for many people to find their friends on Clubhouse and to fit long conversations into their daily lives." They had tried to change the product "with our current team size," they said, "but we haven't been able to do it effectively," and "being remote has made this especially challenging for us."
The relaunch post that September said that after Covid "it became harder to coordinate," so many people saw "whatever rooms happened to be live," which "creates a bad experience for most casual users of live audio."
Neither the email nor the relaunch post names a rival as a cause.
What reporting showed
In February 2021, TechCrunch's Sarah Perez wrote that some wondered "how well social audio apps will fare when the world reopens post-COVID."
By April, CNBC reported signs the buzz was fading. Analyst Matt Navarra told it "the initial FOMO about getting a Clubhouse invite and trying it out has ebbed away." One of users' main gripes, CNBC said, was a lack of relevant rooms.
TechCrunch reported in April 2021 that Twitter, Spotify, Facebook, Telegram, Discord and LinkedIn were "all prepping similar features," and The Verge noted that such rivals "already come with built-in user bases of millions of people." By July, TechCrunch wrote, Facebook, Twitter, Spotify, Discord and "everybody else" had "followed suit, splicing voice chat rooms and voice events into their existing platforms." In 2024, TechCrunch put the fall in downloads down to "people going out more" and alternatives "like Twitter Spaces."
Moderation drew repeated criticism. TechCrunch reported in April 2021 that "anti-Semitic audio rooms seemed to proliferate on the platform." Bloomberg's Ellen Huet wrote in 2023, in a story Fortune ran, that when users first flocked to Clubhouse they also brought "hate speech" and "an unruly lack of moderation," and that "once lockdowns eased, user numbers fell quickly."
What later analysis found
Writing for CNBC on the day of the 2023 layoffs, Ari Levy called Clubhouse the "posterchild for the tech industry's irrational exuberance during the Covid pandemic." Its growth "had flattened before a revenue model was ever put in place," he wrote, and viral apps usually fade "because the novelty disappears or a larger platform creates a copycat."
In 2024, comparing it with the new social app Airchat, TechCrunch's Amanda Silberling wrote that Clubhouse had "no way to block people for months after launch" and "repeatedly played host to antisemitic and misogynistic conversations without consequence."
The stage it reached
Clubhouse is in the decline stage, where usage falls because people have moved to a substitute.
The substitutes were ordinary life after lockdowns, by its founders' account, and audio rooms inside apps people already used, by reporters'. Not all of the rivals lasted. In October 2023, TechCrunch reported that Amazon had shut its live radio app, Amp, and that Meta and Spotify had given up on real-time audio the year before.
On the product life cycle, I count Clubhouse as a decline, not a failure to launch, because it grew to 2 million weekly active users before its usage fell, and it still ran in November 2026.
The lesson
I think Clubhouse is a lesson in telling demand apart from circumstance. Its founders wrote in April 2023 that it "works really well when your friends are on the product and you have the time to meet up." That September, the relaunch post said users had probably seen friends there during Covid "because we were all stuck in our living rooms all day."
Quibi launched an app for watching on the go just as people were advised to shelter in place. Clubhouse had the opposite luck. "We're all locked away right now so it was a good time to launch it," Josh Felser, a venture investor and early user, told CNBC in May 2020.
Clubhouse quadrupled its team in early 2021, its blog said, and raised at a reported $4 billion that April, the month CNBC said the buzz was fading. Two years later it cut more than half its staff.
Davison said in 2022 that "the ideal is to grow at a steady pace." If a surge has an outside cause, measure who stays once that cause passes before you hire and raise for the peak.
Causes at a glance
Company statementTiming
Its founders said reopening made it harder to find friends there and time to talk
Reporting at the timeCompetition
Twitter, Facebook, Spotify and others copied its rooms into platforms millions used
Company statementQuality and reliability
Clubhouse said its 2021 rush broke the app and newcomers couldn't find good rooms
Reporting at the timePrivacy and safety
Antisemitic rooms and thin moderation tools drew criticism from 2021 on
Later analysisBusiness model and costs
Growth flattened before it had a revenue model, CNBC's Ari Levy wrote
Source12
Sources
- 1.Clubhouse (Paul Davison and Rohan Seth), Check 1, 2, 3... Is this thing on?
July 2020 · Company statement
- 2.CNBC, Silicon Valley is going crazy for Clubhouse, a social media app with 1,500 users that's already worth $100 million
May 2020 · Reporting at the time
- 3.TechCrunch, Report: Social audio app Clubhouse has topped 8 million global downloads
February 2021 · Reporting at the time
- 4.The Verge, Twitter reportedly discussed buying social audio app Clubhouse for $4 billion
April 2021 · Reporting at the time
- 5.CNBC, There are signs that the buzz around Clubhouse is already fading, but investors aren't deterred
April 2021 · Reporting at the time
- 6.TechCrunch, Clubhouse closes an undisclosed $4B valuation Series C round, as tech giants' clones circle
April 2021 · Reporting at the time
- 7.TechCrunch, Clubhouse is now out of beta and open to everyone
July 2021 · Reporting at the time
- 8.TechCrunch, Clubhouse's Paul Davison on Twitter, the impact of hype and what happened
October 2022 · Reporting at the time
- 9.Clubhouse (Paul Davison and Rohan Seth), Founders' email to Clubhouse employees
April 2023 · Company statement
- 10.TechCrunch, Clubhouse needs to fix things, and today it cut more than half of staff
April 2023 · Reporting at the time
- 11.Fortune (Bloomberg), Clubhouse goes from a buzzy pandemic-era chat startup frequented by Oprah and Elon Musk to slashing its workforce by more than half
April 2023 · Reporting at the time
- 12.CNBC, The pandemic drove Clubhouse to a $4 billion valuation that never looked sustainable
April 2023 · Later analysis
- 13.Clubhouse, the new clubhouse
September 2023 · Company statement
- 14.TechCrunch, Amazon turns off the volume on Amp, its live radio app
October 2023 · Reporting at the time
- 15.TechCrunch, Clubhouse's new feature turns your texts into custom voice messages
February 2024 · Reporting at the time
- 16.TechCrunch, Airchat, the buzzy new social app, could be great - or, it could succumb to the same fate as Clubhouse
April 2024 · Later analysis
- 17.Google Play (Alpha Exploration Co.), Clubhouse
October 2026 · Company statement
More from the graveyard
Jan 2017
Vine
Twitter Social networks
Twitter turned off Vine's social features on January 17, 2017, leaving Vine Camera and an archive
Dec 2020
Quibi
Quibi Streaming
The app stopped working on December 1, 2020; Roku bought its content distribution rights in January 2021
Sep 2014
Orkut
Google Social networks
Google shut Orkut down on September 30, 2014