Social networks NOV 20, 2026 6 MIN READ
Google Buzz
My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.
The timeline as text
- February 9, 2010Launched inside Gmail, auto-following users' most frequent contacts
- February 13, 2010Google says it will swap auto-follow for auto-suggest, and apologizes
- February 2010Electronic Privacy Information Center files an FTC complaint
- November 2, 2010Google emails US Gmail users about an $8.5 million settlement
- March 30, 2011FTC announces a proposed settlement with 20 years of privacy audits
- October 14, 2011Google says Buzz will shut down within weeks, to focus on Google+
- October 24, 2011FTC gives final approval to the settlement
- December 2011Google's help page says Buzz has been retired
- Company
- Category
- Social networks
- Launched
- February 2010
- Ended
- December 2011
- Stage reached
- Introduction
- AI product
- No
- Status
- Google retired Buzz in December 2011, about two months after saying it would focus on Google+
Google Buzz failed because its launch inside Gmail set people up to follow the contacts they emailed and chatted with most, without adequately disclosing that those contacts would become public by default, the FTC later charged. Four days in, Google promised new defaults, but CNN reported that Buzz hadn't caught on by September 2010, and in 2011 Google shut it down, saying it would focus on Google+.
What it was
Google Buzz was a social sharing service built into Gmail, for posting updates, links, photos and videos publicly or privately.
Todd Jackson, its product manager, introduced it on February 9, 2010. Because it lived in Gmail, he wrote, "you don't have to peck out an entirely new set of friends from scratch."
Buzz did that work for you "by automatically setting you up to follow the people you email and chat with the most."
Google showed it off at a press conference at its Mountain View headquarters, with co-founder Sergey Brin on hand, the Los Angeles Times reported. The paper said Buzz was taking on Facebook and Twitter.
What happened
Google Buzz drew privacy complaints within two days of its February 2010 launch, and two settlements followed.
On February 11, Jackson wrote that "tens of millions of people have checked Buzz out." The same post answered concern that contacts "were being made public without their knowledge," and made the option to hide those lists easier to find.
On February 13, Google said it would replace auto-follow with an "auto-suggest model." It would also add a setting to turn Buzz off. "We're very sorry for the concern we've caused," Jackson wrote.
A week after launch, the Electronic Privacy Information Center filed a complaint with the FTC, The Washington Post reported.
On November 2, 2010, Google emailed every Gmail user in the US about a settlement with a group of Buzz users who had sued it, TechCrunch reported. Google committed $8.5 million to an independent fund, "most of which will support organizations promoting privacy education and policy on the web."
The FTC announced a proposed settlement on March 30, 2011, that would require Google to run a "comprehensive privacy program," with independent audits every two years for 20 years.
On October 14, 2011, Bradley Horowitz, Google's vice president of product, wrote that Google would shut down Buzz and its API "in a few weeks" and "focus instead on Google+." Ten days later, on October 24, the FTC gave the settlement final approval.
By late December 2011, Google's help page read, "We've retired Google Buzz."
Why it failed
Google admitted the launch fell short on privacy and on testing. Reporting added that Buzz didn't catch on even after Google tweaked its settings.
What Google said
On the day the FTC announced its proposed settlement, Alma Whitten, Google's director of privacy for product and engineering, wrote that "the launch of Google Buzz fell short of our usual standards for transparency and user control."
A week after launch, BBC News reported that Google had admitted its testing of Buzz was insufficient. Jackson told the BBC that "getting feedback from 20,000 Googlers isn't quite the same as letting Gmail users play with Buzz in the wild."
In September 2010, Horowitz said Buzz had "stumbled out of the gate," CNN reported.
The shutdown post gave focus on Google+ as the reason. It said, "We learned a lot from products like Buzz." The post doesn't give usage figures.
What reporting showed
CNET's Molly Wood wrote on February 11, 2010, two days after launch, that Buzz "publicly reveals my personal contact list without asking me."
The Guardian's Charles Arthur blamed the testing. Google had tested Buzz internally "a great deal," he wrote, "but the weakness of that is that it doesn't have many people who really hate each other internally."
In 2011 the FTC charged that Google "failed to disclose adequately that consumers' frequent email contacts would become public by default." It alleged that some people who clicked "Nah, go to my inbox" were still enrolled in parts of Buzz. A consent agreement isn't an admission that the law was broken, the FTC noted.
Wired's Steven Levy wrote in June 2011 that Buzz's innovations "never had a chance to win an audience" once privacy flaws in its initial design set off an internet firestorm. He traced the "train wreck" to "Google's failure to test Buzz externally before its launch."
Ars Technica's Ryan Paul wrote in his first look at Buzz that "there isn't much in Buzz that is new or original." In September 2010, CNN reported that Buzz "hasn't caught on in the crowded social-media field," calling it a "me too" effort with few distinguishing features.
Covering the settlement email, TechCrunch's MG Siegler wrote that it didn't address what was "perhaps the more troubling issue about Buzz: its usefulness, or lack-thereof."
What later analysis found
Mashable's 2015 history of Google+, based on interviews with more than a dozen insiders and analysts, said Buzz "imploded fast in early 2010 after a catastrophic privacy issue." It reported that Buzz "had barely a dozen people on staff," against "upwards of 1,000" for Google+.
Paul Adams, a former member of the Google+ user experience team, told Mashable there was "a bit of a fallout from Google Buzz," with the question "how did we get it so wrong and what do we do now?"
In May 2013, reporting that Google would save Buzz posts to people's Google Drive, Business Insider's headline called it "The Social Network No One Cared About."
The stage it reached
Buzz never left the introduction stage, the launch period when almost nobody beyond early adopters has used a product.
Google's figure of tens of millions of first looks in two days sounds like more than that. I don't count them, because Google was rolling Buzz out to every Gmail account.
Like Google+ after it, Buzz got its first numbers from a Google product people already used. Seven months in, CNN reported it hadn't caught on.
It never found a market to lose, so on the product life cycle I count it as a failure, not a decline.
The lesson
I think the defaults are the launch. Buzz shipped with a way to hide your follower list, and Google's first fix, two days in, answered complaints that the checkbox was "too hard to find."
The shortcut that made Buzz easy to start was the one that caused the backlash. Google built it on Gmail so nobody had to "peck out" a new set of friends, and that, the FTC charged, put the people you email most on a public list by default without adequate disclosure.
Jackson named the gap himself when he said 20,000 Googlers weren't quite the same as Gmail users in the wild. If a feature reuses data people gave you for something else, run user acceptance testing outside the building first, with people whose contact lists look like your users'.
Google+ opened as a field test with outsiders, Wired reported, and you added people to circles by hand. I'd copy both.
Causes at a glance
Company statementPrivacy and safety
Google said the launch fell short of its standards for transparency and user control
Company statementRushed launch
BBC News reported that Google admitted its testing of Buzz was insufficient
Reporting at the timeWeak demand
CNN reported in September 2010 that Buzz hadn't caught on
Reporting at the timeUnclear value
Ars Technica found little in it that was new, and CNN called it a "me too" effort
Company statementChange of company strategy
Google shut it down to focus instead on Google+
Source15
Sources
- 1.Google, Introducing Google Buzz
February 2010 · Company statement
- 2.Los Angeles Times, Google aims to take on Facebook with new social feature called 'Buzz'
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 3.Gmail Blog (Google), Millions of Buzz users, and improvements based on your feedback
February 2010 · Company statement
- 4.CNET, Google Buzz: Privacy nightmare
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 5.Ars Technica, First look at Buzz: much potential, not much innovation yet
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 6.The Guardian, Google Buzz's open approach leads to stalking threat
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 7.Gmail Blog (Google), A new Buzz start-up experience based on your feedback
February 2010 · Company statement
- 8.BBC News, Google admits Buzz social network testing flaws
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 9.The Washington Post, Privacy advocates file FTC complaint on Google Buzz
February 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 10.CNN Money, What Google learned from its Buzz 'stumble'
September 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 11.TechCrunch, Google Emails All U.S. Gmail Users About The Buzz Settlement: And To Say They're Not Getting A Dime
November 2010 · Reporting at the time
- 12.Federal Trade Commission, FTC Charges Deceptive Privacy Practices in Google's Rollout of Its Buzz Social Network
March 2011 · Reporting at the time
- 13.Google, An update on Buzz
March 2011 · Company statement
- 14.Wired, Inside Google+: How the Search Giant Plans to Go Social
June 2011 · Reporting at the time
- 15.Google, A fall sweep
October 2011 · Company statement
- 16.Federal Trade Commission, FTC Gives Final Approval to Settlement with Google over Buzz Rollout
October 2011 · Reporting at the time
- 17.Gmail Help (Google), Google Buzz has gone away, but your posts are yours to keep
December 2011 · Company statement
- 18.Business Insider, Google Buzz, The Social Network No One Cared About, Is Finally Going Offline
May 2013 · Later analysis
- 19.Mashable, Inside the failure of Google+, a very expensive attempt to unseat Facebook
August 2015 · Later analysis
More from the graveyard
Apr 2019
Google+
Google Social networks
Consumer Google+ shut down on April 2, 2019; its workplace successor, Currents, closed in 2023
Sep 2014
Orkut
Google Social networks
Google shut Orkut down on September 30, 2014
Mar 2023
Google Glass
Google Wearables
Google stopped selling Glass Enterprise Edition on March 15, 2023