Assistants and chatbots AI NOV 22, 2026 6 MIN READ

Cortana

My post on failed products examples covers twelve famous cases from tech and why each one failed.

The Harman Kardon Invoke, a tall dark metal smart speaker, on a wooden floor, with the blue Cortana ring on its top lit
Photo by Jdubman (resized) · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Source
Timeline of Cortana: 8 dated events from April 2, 2014 to June 2024, drawn from the entry's sources.Timeline of Cortana: 8 dated events from April 2, 2014 to June 2024, drawn from the entry's sources.
Every date is from the entry's sources below. An original diagram, free to reuse with a link to this page · Download the SVG
The timeline as text
  • April 2, 2014Unveiled at Microsoft's Build conference as part of Windows Phone 8.1
  • December 9, 2015Released for iOS and Android in the US and China
  • January 2019Nadella said Microsoft no longer saw it as an Alexa rival
  • July 31, 2020Microsoft said it would end the mobile apps and third-party skills
  • March 31, 2021Microsoft discontinued the iOS and Android apps
  • June 2, 2023Microsoft said it would stop supporting the Windows app in late 2023
  • May 22, 2024Microsoft said Windows 11 version 24H2 removes Cortana
  • June 2024Its last features, in Outlook mobile, were retired
Company
Microsoft
Category
Assistants and chatbots
Launched
April 2014
Ended
June 2024
Stage reached
Introduction
AI product
Yes
Status
Microsoft retired its last Cortana features, in Outlook mobile, in June 2024

Cortana failed because it lost the home to Amazon's Alexa and Google Assistant, and only one smart speaker ever ran it. Microsoft started aiming it at work in 2019 and retired the last of it in June 2024.

What it was

Cortana was Microsoft's voice assistant, named after the AI character in the Halo video games and built mostly on Bing's back-end services.

Microsoft unveiled it at its Build conference on April 2, 2014, as part of Windows Phone 8.1, Business Insider reported. "We think Cortana is the most personal digital assistant," Microsoft's Joe Belfiore said during the demo.

It launched as a beta, in the US only, on Windows Phone. The Verge's Tom Warren wrote that it arrived with "the competition already years ahead," at a time when Microsoft was trying to catch up in mobile.

What happened

Cortana moved from Windows Phone to the desktop and to rival phones, then lost its consumer features one by one.

It came to the desktop with Windows 10 in 2015, Ars Technica wrote later, and The Verge reported its release for iOS and Android in the US and China on December 9, 2015.

Microsoft's 2016 annual report said the "Windows 10 Cortana search box" had "over 126 million monthly active users."

The only Cortana smart speaker, Harman Kardon's Invoke, cost $199 when The Verge reviewed it in October 2017. GeekWire noted that it came more than two years after Amazon's Echo.

Microsoft and Amazon started a preview in August 2018 that let Cortana and Alexa call each other, a link-up they had announced the year before.

In January 2019, CEO Satya Nadella told reporters that Microsoft no longer saw Cortana as a competitor to Alexa or Google Assistant, The Verge reported. The May 2019 Windows 10 update split Cortana from the taskbar search box, and at Build that month The Verge saw Microsoft aiming it at "workers who are organizing their days."

On July 31, 2020, Microsoft said it would end third-party Cortana skills that September and stop supporting the iOS and Android apps in early 2021. Microsoft discontinued the mobile apps on March 31, 2021. That month, The Verge reported, Harman Kardon was pushing an update to remove Cortana from the Invoke.

On June 2, 2023, a week after Microsoft unveiled Windows Copilot, it said it would stop supporting Cortana as a standalone Windows app in late 2023, Windows Central reported. By August, Ars Technica reported the app was due to stop working that month.

Microsoft's notes for Windows 11 version 24H2, in May 2024, said Cortana was removed after the upgrade. Its end-of-support page says the last pieces, voice search and Play My Emails in Outlook mobile, were retired in June 2024.

Why it failed

Reporters said Cortana fell behind Alexa and Google Assistant once assistants moved into home devices, and Microsoft answered by recasting it as a work assistant before retiring it.

What Microsoft said

Microsoft described its cuts from 2019 to 2021 as a move toward productivity, and its July 2020 note also cited lower usage.

In May 2018, Javier Soltero, then Microsoft's corporate vice president for Cortana, told ZDNet that the market for home devices had been "shaped differently when we expected." ZDNet's Mary Jo Foley reported him saying Microsoft saw that market might matter "but didn't jump quickly on."

In January 2019, Nadella said, "Cortana needs to be that skill for anybody who's a Microsoft 365 subscriber," one people could use on Alexa or Google Assistant. The Verge reported that he admitted the challenge of building hardware and software unique enough to compete.

When Microsoft confirmed in November 2019 that the mobile app would disappear in eight countries, including the UK and India, a spokesperson told The Verge the company was "integrating Cortana deeper into your Microsoft 365 productivity apps."

Microsoft's July 2020 note said it was changing some "U.S. consumer-centric features and functionalities with lower usage." It added that most Invoke owners "primarily use the Invoke to play music because of its premium quality sound."

Andrew Shuman, the corporate vice president in charge of Cortana, had told PCWorld that May, "With the Invoke, all we saw with any reliability was playing music."

Microsoft's end-of-support page now points Cortana users to voice access in Windows 11 and to Copilot.

What reporting showed

The Verge's Tom Warren wrote after CES in January 2018 that "it was all about Alexa vs. Google Assistant," and that apart from a thermostat announced the year before, no new Cortana devices were unveiled.

By August 2018 he wrote that Cortana had "fallen far behind both Alexa and Google Assistant." Apart from that thermostat, he added, it hadn't started showing up in more speakers, cars, fridges or toasters as Microsoft had promised.

In The Verge's Invoke review, Dan Seifert found that Cortana couldn't see his Google Calendar appointments. It couldn't control his Todoist lists either, which he could do with the Echo or Google Home.

On phones, The Verge wrote in 2021 that the iOS and Android app "failed to gain traction despite a big redesign." MacRumors said it "apparently never gained a user base big enough" for Microsoft to keep it.

What later analysis found

The only later account I found comes from a former Microsoft executive rather than an outside analyst.

Qi Lu had worked on Cortana before he left Microsoft for Baidu. He told Wired in 2017 that Google and Microsoft had been ahead of Amazon technologically "by a wide margin."

Amazon pulled ahead anyway, in his account. "They got the device right," he said. Alexa was "an AI-first device," while the phone would stay "a finger-first, mobile-first device" for the foreseeable future.

"Microsoft and Google made the same mistake," Lu said. "We focused on Cortana on the phone and PC, particularly the phone."

The stage it reached

Cortana never left the introduction stage, even though it came built into Windows 10.

The 126 million figure reads like growth. I think it mostly measures Windows 10, because it counted the taskbar search box, which Microsoft split from Cortana in 2019. What Microsoft said later, about music on the Invoke and lower usage, points the other way.

I made the same call on 3D TV. A feature that ships with the product isn't one I'd count as having found a market until people choose to use it, so I count Cortana as a failure, not a decline.

The lesson

I think Cortana's lesson is to count the job, not the placement.

Windows 10 gave Cortana a box on the taskbar and a monthly number Microsoft could print in its annual report. Neither said whether people wanted an assistant.

The Invoke told Microsoft more. By the company's own account in 2020, its owners mostly played music on it.

If I were building an assistant today, I'd track the tasks people ask for again without a prompt, and drop the ones nobody repeats. That's also why I recommend that a business start with a workflow, not with AI.

Causes at a glance

  • Reporting at the timeCompetition

    Alexa and Google Assistant took the home while Cortana reached one speaker

    Sources7,8,10,11,20

  • Company statementTiming

    Microsoft's Cortana chief said in 2018 that the company was slow to move on home devices

    Sources9,8

  • Later analysisUnclear value

    A former executive said Microsoft focused it on the phone, not an AI-first device

    Sources5,6

  • Company statementWeak demand

    In 2020 Microsoft cut consumer features it said had lower usage

    Sources16,17

  • Company statementChange of company strategy

    In 2019 Nadella said it should be a Microsoft 365 skill, not an Alexa rival

    Sources12,14,24

Sources

  1. 1.
    Business Insider, Microsoft Has Its Own Version Of Siri, A Voice Assistant Called 'Cortana'

    April 2014 · Reporting at the time

  2. 2.
    The Verge, The story of Cortana, Microsoft's Siri killer

    April 2014 · Reporting at the time

  3. 3.
    The Verge, Microsoft's Cortana assistant now available on iOS and Android

    December 2015 · Reporting at the time

  4. 4.
    Microsoft, Microsoft 2016 Annual Report

    October 2016 · Company statement

  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
    The Verge, Harman Kardon Invoke review: Cortana gets a speaker of its own

    October 2017 · Reporting at the time

  8. 8.
  9. 9.
  10. 10.
    The Verge, Microsoft and Amazon release preview of Cortana and Alexa integration

    August 2018 · Reporting at the time

  11. 11.
    The Verge, Microsoft's Cortana falls behind Alexa and Google Assistant at CES

    January 2018 · Reporting at the time

  12. 12.
  13. 13.
  14. 14.
    The Verge, Microsoft is making Cortana better at holding conversations

    May 2019 · Reporting at the time

  15. 15.
    The Verge, Microsoft is killing off its Cortana app for iOS and Android in January

    November 2019 · Reporting at the time

  16. 16.
    Microsoft, Upcoming changes to Cortana

    July 2020 · Company statement

  17. 17.
    PCWorld, Why Cortana won't be at Microsoft Build

    May 2020 · Reporting at the time

  18. 18.
    The Verge, Microsoft shuts down Cortana on iOS and Android

    April 2021 · Reporting at the time

  19. 19.
    MacRumors, Microsoft Shuts Down Cortana App for iOS and Android

    March 2021 · Reporting at the time

  20. 20.
  21. 21.
    Windows Central, Microsoft is killing Cortana on Windows 11 and Windows 10 later this year

    June 2023 · Reporting at the time

  22. 22.
  23. 23.
    Microsoft (Windows Insider Blog), Releasing Windows 11, version 24H2 to the Release Preview Channel

    May 2024 · Company statement

  24. 24.
    Microsoft, End of support for Cortana

    Company statement

Share this entry